Her parents were injured in a Tesla crash. She ended up having to pay Tesla damages
Over the last four years, Tesla has sued at least six car owners who had sudden vehicle malfunctions, quality complaints or accidents they claimed were caused by mechanical failures.
By ELSIE CHEN, ERIKA KINETZ and DAKE KANG | Associated Press
BEIJINGÂ â Zhang Yazhou was sitting in the passenger seat of her Tesla Model 3 when she said she heard her fatherâs panicked voice: The brakes donât work! Approaching a red light, her father swerved around two cars before plowing into an SUV and a sedan and crashing into a large concrete barrier.
Stunned, Zhang gazed at the deflating airbag in front of her. She could never have imagined what was to come: Tesla sued her for defamation for complaining publicly about the carâs brakes â and won. A Chinese court ordered Zhang to pay more than $23,000 in damages and publicly apologize to the $1.1 trillion company.
RELATED:Â Tesla fined for âseriousâ heat violation at Fremont plant
Zhang is not the only one to find herself in the crosshairs of Tesla, which is led by Elon Musk, among the richest men in the world and a self-described â free speech absolutist.â Over the last four years, Tesla has sued at least six car owners in China who had sudden vehicle malfunctions, quality complaints or accidents they claimed were caused by mechanical failures.
The company has also sued at least six bloggers and two Chinese media outlets that wrote critically about the company, according to a review of public court documents and Chinese media reports by The Associated Press. Tesla won all eleven cases for which AP could determine the verdicts. Two judgments, including Zhangâs, are on appeal. One case was settled out of court.It is not common practice for automakers â in China or elsewhere â to sue their customers. But Tesla has pioneered an aggressive legal strategy and leveraged the patronage of powerful leaders in Chinaâs ruling Communist Party to silence critics, reap financial rewards and limit its accountability.
The AP review of Teslaâs record in China comes as Musk is wielding significant influence in President Donald Trumpâs new administration, leading an effort to rapidly shrink the size of the federal government and oust employees deemed disloyal to the president. His actions have raised concerns that Musk is weakening the U.S. system of checks and balances, in part, to benefit Tesla and his other companies.
In the United States, Musk has found a powerful ally in Trump. Together, they have ransacked the federal government, freezing spending, suspending programs and dismissing prosecutors, government watchdogs and others that have traditionally acted as guardrails.
Tesla officials in China and the United States did not reply to requests for comment.
Teslaâs record in China shows how Musk has thrived in a system in which regulators, the media and the courts â which must all ultimately answer to the ruling Communist Party â are, by design, somewhat intertwined.
Tesla has profited from the largesse of the Chinese state, winning unprecedented regulatory benefits, below-market rate loans and large tax breaks. With a few pointed exceptions, Tesla has enjoyed largely ingratiating coverage in the Chinese press, and journalists told AP they have been instructed to avoid negative coverage of the automaker.
Teslaâs windfall has extended to the courts â and not just in legal actions Tesla has brought against customers. In a review of public court documents, AP found that Tesla won nearly 90% of civil cases over safety, quality or contract disputes brought by customers.
âThe government gave Tesla a super status that put consumers in a very vulnerable position,â said Qiao Yudong, a former lawyer for American sports car company Saleen Automotive in China. âThatâs why some consumers had to resort to extreme actions.â
One of those desperate customers was Zhang.
Burning with angerThe February 2021 crash in central Chinaâs Henan province sent Zhangâs mother and father, who had a concussion, to the hospital for four days, medical records show. Zhang â who was unharmed in the accident, as was her baby niece â wanted to understand what had happened: How could her dream car have turned into such a nightmare?
Traffic police determined that the crash was her dadâs fault because he hadnât maintained a safe following distance. Zhang, however, insisted that the brakes had malfunctioned, sending the car out of control. She filed a complaint with a local market regulator, requesting a refund and compensation. Teslas are among the most computerized cars on the market, so Zhang asked the automaker to turn over the full pre-crash data from her car, hoping it might help explain what went wrong. Tesla refused.
âTeslaâs employees were very arrogant and tough in dealing with my complaints,â Zhang said in an interview. âI was burning with anger.â
After weeks of stewing, she draped her damaged car with a banner proclaiming âTesla brake failureâ in front of the Tesla dealership in Zhengzhou, the capital of Henan province, some 200 km (124 miles) from her home. She sat on the Teslaâs roof and blared her protest through a bullhorn: âTesla Model 3 brakes failed,â she said. âA family of four almost died.â The next month, she parked her damaged car outside an auto show in Zhengzhou. It was all to no avail â Tesla refused to turn over the full data and mediation went nowhere.
Figuring that top Tesla officials would attend an April auto show in Shanghai, she and a friend â who had also had a problem with her Tesla â donned matching T-shirts with the phrase âBrakes failâ and headed for Teslaâs booth, determined to buttonhole executives. The automakerâs officials avoided them, Zhang said, and they couldnât get anyone to hear them out.
Her friend, who was six months pregnant, started shouting, âTesla brakes fail!â
Zhang clambered on top of a shiny red display model and started hollering, too.
âThings escalated,â said Zhang.
The moment â captured on cell phone videos shot by onlookers â went viral on Chinese social media. Burly security guards hauled Zhang out, and she was detained for five days.
Some observers speculated that Zhangâs protest had been orchestrated â perhaps by a competitor or by the Chinese government itself to pressure Tesla to conform with Chinese regulations. Tesla alleged that Zhang hadnât acted on her own. A top executive speculated to Chinese media that she âhad someone behind herâ and said Zhang was making a fuss because she just wanted higher compensation.
Zhang insisted she acted on her own â and out of anguish. Outraged, she sued Tesla for defamation, arguing that the executiveâs comments unjustly cast her as a troublemaker to deflect attention from the companyâs own shortcomings.
And then she found herself on the receiving end of a lawsuit filed by Tesla.
The odds are against youTesla said Zhang had deliberately spread false information that damaged the brand and asked for 5 million yuan ($684,000) in damages.
The case, which a court took up in October 2021, came as Tesla faced a barrage of criticism in China.
Dozens of Tesla owners had been publicly complaining about alleged brake failures, battery fires, unintended acceleration and other defects, as well as what they claimed were misleading sales practices. The same month as Zhangâs crash, Chinese regulators summoned Tesla to respond to quality concerns raised by such reports.
Zhangâs emotional protest sparked a rare burst of criticism of Tesla in Chinese media. Under pressure from regulators, Tesla finally released the data from her car, which the company said showed her father had been driving nearly 120 km per hour (75 mph) and that the brakes had functioned to reduce the magnitude of the collision.
Tesla had finally given Zhang what sheâd been asking for, but theyâd published the data publicly and included her vehicle identification number. She said she and her family started getting threatened and doxed online. Besides, she wondered, how could she be sure Tesla hadnât modified or redacted the data from her car? It was less than the victory sheâd hoped for. Feeling besieged, she sued Tesla a second time, in March 2022, for invading her privacy.
Zhang lost both cases she brought against Tesla.
Meanwhile, the defamation case against her was grinding along. Back in court as a defendant, Zhang was unable to prove that the brakes on her Tesla had indeed failed. In a closed trial, a Shanghai court ruled in May 2024 that Zhangâs public complaints went beyond what magistrates considered reasonable, factual criticism and ordered her to publicly apologize and pay 170,000 RMB ($23,000) to cover damages and the legal costs of the worldâs most valuable car company.
Zhang appealed the ruling. She maintains that her lawsuit is a cry for transparency and accountability and that a company as rich and powerful as Tesla should be able to tolerate legitimate criticism from its customers.
âI refuse to accept it,â Zhang told the Associated Press, âAs a consumer, even if I said something wrong, I have the right to comment and criticize. I spoke about my feelings as a user of the car. It has nothing to do with damaging their reputation.â
Her odds of winning the appeal against Tesla do not look good. Tesla has not only won the defamation cases it brought against unhappy car owners and critical journalists, itâs also prevailed in lawsuits customers have filed against it.
An AP review of a Chinese government database of court filings published online found 81 civil judgements in which car owners sued Tesla over safety and quality issues or contract disputes. Car owners won in only nine of those cases.
In a statement to AP, the Shanghai High Peopleâs Court said that judgments are the result of a âfair trialâ based on âthe objective facts of the case.â
âIt cannot be assumed that the party has received âspecial protectionâ or âspecial treatmentâ because of their victory,â the court wrote.
While some auto industry experts in China say itâs generally difficult for customers to win cases against car companies, others say itâs remarkable for a foreign company to enjoy such blazing success in Chinese courts.
âFor Tesla to win that percentage of the time is an anomaly,â said Bill Russo, founder of Automobility Ltd., an advisory firm based in Shanghai, who also used to be regional head of Chrysler in northeast Asia. âThe odds are stacked against you. Itâs like going to the casino and winning every hand.â
The power of patronageTeslaâs commercial and political success in China has hinged on the support of a powerful patron: Li Qiang, the former party boss of Shanghai who is now Chinaâs premier, second in rank only to President Xi Jinping. It was under his watch, in 2019, that Tesla built its first overseas factory on the outskirts of Chinaâs financial capital.
With Liâs support, Tesla became the first foreign automaker allowed to retain complete control over its China venture and got low-interest loans and generous tax breaks. China also adopted an emissions credit scheme modeled after a U.S. program that has generated billions in income for Tesla.
In January 2020, one year after breaking ground, Elon Musk unveiled the first Chinese-made Teslas on a stage in Shanghai. Tesla turned an annual profit for the first time in its history that year, and Musk was declared the worldâs richest person in January 2021.
China got what it wanted, too: Tesla was a potent catalyst for domestic production and consumption. Before Teslaâs arrival, new energy vehicles accounted for around five percent of Chinaâs auto market. Today, analysts say, more than half of passenger vehicles sold retail in China are powered by an electric motor. Chinese battery maker CATL, a key Tesla supplier, has embedded itself in global supply chains to become the worldâs largest EV-battery maker. Chinaâs BYD is now the worldâs largest electric vehicle manufacturer and a growing competitive threat to legacy carmakers in the West.
âTesla had a large part to play in that,â said Tu Le, the managing director of Sino Auto Insights, a consulting firm. Tu said the way the government smoothed the way for Muskâs factory was critical. âIt was a swampy field on the outskirts of Shanghai. A year later theyâre rolling cars off the line,â he said. âI donât know if that happens anywhere else in the world.â
Requests for comment to the State Council, which is run by Li Qiang and oversees Chinaâs government ministries, went unanswered.
Musk still swings by to meet Li when he goes to China. Their encounters underscore the complexity of Muskâs overlapping interests as a businessman and the most China-friendly member of Trumpâs inner circle.
Muskâs âgreater objective was winning influence over the people that mattered for him, that enabled him to get things done,â said Russo, the auto strategist in Shanghai. âHeâs done a good job of it in China and heâs done it now with the influence he purchased with his relationship with Trump.â
A chilling effectSafety advocates worry about the implications of Muskâs proximity to power in the United States. Federal investigations and safety initiatives Musk has long railed against could be easily snuffed out by the new administration.
In the U.S., Tesla also has been subject to a raft of customer safety complaints and lawsuits over autopilot function, battery charging, alleged suspension defects, sudden braking or acceleration, faulty airbags and allegedly monopolistic practices on repairs and parts. Judges have dismissed some cases. In others, Tesla settled out of court or paid hefty settlements.
Tesla has not publicly sued any of its U.S. customers for speaking out, though in January, Musk said on X that âmaybe it is timeâ to sue media outlets for coverage that could stain Teslaâs brand. His post has been viewed more than 22 million times.
Tesla has already successfully done that in China.
Two Chinese journalists based in Shanghai told AP there is an unwritten rule to avoid critical coverage of Tesla. Both spoke on condition of anonymity, fearing retaliation.
âWe were told by our editor that we should not write negatively about Tesla because it is a key company that was introduced and protected by the Shanghai government,â a tech reporter told AP.
Those who have strayed have found themselves in court. Muskâs company sued media outlets PingWest and ifeng.com over negative coverage. It was unhappy about PingWestâs report that claimed Teslaâs Shanghai factory was a âsweatshop.â The news website ifeng.com drew Teslaâs ire over a story that explored the tribulations of car owners who fought Tesla. PingWest had to apologize and pay Tesla 100,000 yuan ($13,700). AP could not determine the outcome of the case against ifeng.com.
Tesla is not the only company in its industry to sue its critics. BYD has also aggressively pursued media in court, including an unsuccessful lawsuit against Vice Media in the United States. More recently, electric vehicle makers Nio and Li Auto have stepped up defamation cases against bloggers in China who allegedly spread false information about their companies.
Tesla, however, stands out even among its cut-throat Chinese competitors â in going after car owners who suffered crashes.
âTesla used their legal advantages to bully Chinese car owners and people who speak up for them,â said Feng Shiming, an auto blogger and Tesla owner who was ordered by a Shanghai court last year to pay Tesla 250,000 yuan ($34,200) after he wrote about Teslaâs alleged brake failures. He has appealed the verdict. âTesla wants to have a chilling effect on society and terrify people so they will be scared to say anything negative about Tesla.â
Chen Junyi got the message. He lost control of his Model 3 and plowed into a dozen cars in a parking lot at high speed in August 2020. He claimed the brakes had failed. He told Chinese media at the time that he broke his back and four ribs and had to have 30 centimeters (12 inches) of his small intestine removed. Chen took to social media and warned people not to buy Tesla, raising his shirt to reveal the long, gnarled scar that runs up his abdomen.
Tesla maintained the accident was Chenâs fault, citing a technical review that found the car was accelerating and not braking in the seconds before the crash, and sued him for making false claims.
âTesla should proactively respond to consumers instead of using its superior resources and filing lawsuits against consumers who are at a disadvantage,â Chen said in a court statement reviewed by AP. âI almost lost my life because of the car accident. I lost my job and income. I am under tremendous economic pressure.â
Chen declined to speak with the AP, citing fear of retaliation. A Chinese court ordered Chen to pay the carmaker 50,000 yuan ($6,800) as compensation â and to issue an apology.
âI deeply regret the serious negative impacts I have had on Tesla and its cars,â he wrote. âI hereby sincerely apologize to Tesla and to the people who were misled by my remarks.â
A month later, he apologized for his apology, saying the words were not his own.
___
Chen and Kinetz reported from Washington.
___
Contact APâs global investigative team at Investigative@ap.org or https://www.ap.org/tips/
To all those whoâd ground him, take a message back from me: Sam Wilson is flying high, defying gravity! Wait. Wrong movie. However, itâs no less true! Sam Wilson (Anthony Mackie) is CapâŚ
Read more >> : Cick here
 |
 |
 |
 |
 is Cap⌠%23anthonymackie) |
 |
 |
âJada was a big help,â Tennant recalled. âShe kind of seconded some of my instincts.â
Read more >> : Cick here
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe also revealed that the country held �2.62 million worth of Israeli government bonds at the end of 2023
Read more >> : Cick here
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Anthony Mackie and Harrison Ford star in the 35th film in the Marvel Cinematic Universe coming to theaters Feb. 14.
Read more >> : Cick here
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
The Stranger Things actress married Jon Bon Jovi's son in 2024
Read more >> : Cick here
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
EMMERDALE legend Tony Audenshaw is aiming to fulfil his late wifeâs dying wish â by raising funds with a charity with close personal meaning. Tony has portrayed the beloved Bob Hope in âŚ
Read more >> : Cick here
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Mackie's slyly dogged Captain America has less superpower than his predecessor, and so does this movie. But it does wriggle out of superhero fatigue.
Read more >> : Cick here
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Essentially every player made their mark on this game, including some Philadelphia Eagles having the game of their lives.
Read more >> : Cick here
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Dive into a future L.A., a past Ireland, and the Walled City with these three action movies on Amazon Prime Video you need to watch in February 2025.
Read more >> : Cick here
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Chip Ganassi Racing is the latest IndyCar Series team to present its new colors for one of its entries. Sophomore IndyCar driver Kyffin Simpson returns in the renumbered No. 8 Honda â a changâŚ
Read more >> : Cick here
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Twitter (X), Inc. was an American social media company based in San Francisco, California, which operated and was named for its flagship social media network prior to its rebrand as X. In addition to Twitter, the company previously operated the Vine short video app and Periscope livestreaming service
Twitter (X) is one of the most popular social media platforms, with over 619 million monthly active users worldwide. One of the most exciting features of Twitter (X) is the ability to see what topics are trending in real-time. Twitter trends are a fascinating way to stay up to date on what people are talking about on the platform, and they can also be a valuable tool for businesses and individuals to stay relevant and informed. In this article, we will discuss Twitter (X) trends, how they work, and how you can use them to your advantage.
What are Twitter (X) Worldwide Trends?
Twitter (X) Worldwide trends are a list of topics that are currently being talked about on the platform and also world. The topics on this list change in real-time and are based on the volume of tweets using a particular hashtag or keyword. Twitter (X) Worldwide trends can be localized to a Worldwide country or region or can be global, depending on the topic's popularity.
How Do Twitter (X) Worldwide Trends Work?
Twitter (X) Worldwide trends are generated by an algorithm that analyzes the volume of tweets using a particular hashtag or keyword. When the algorithm detects a sudden increase in tweets using a specific hashtag or keyword, it considers that topic to be trending.
Once a topic is identified as trending, it is added to the list of Twitter (X) Worldwide trends. The topics on this list are ranked based on their popularity, with the most popular topics appearing at the top of the list.
Twitter (X) Worldwide trends can be filtered by location or category, allowing users to see what topics are trending in their area or in a particular industry. Additionally, users can click on a trending topic to see all of the tweets using that hashtag or keyword.