More kids, less backstory: The differences between the film and the short story of ‘The Monkey’ | The Mary Sue

Stephen King's story "The Monkey" is a film from Osgood Perkins. Perkins' adaptation is a brilliant take on the short story. But it is very different from
More kids, less backstory: The differences between the film and the short story of ‘The Monkey’ | The Mary Sue

👉 Click Here to read in detail 👈


Stephen King’s story “The Monkey” is a film from Osgood Perkins. Perkins’ adaptation is a brilliant take on the short story. But it is very different from King’s work, which is in the short story collection called Skeleton Crew.

Recommended Videos

The differences between King’s work and Perkins’ take on the story are vastly different, comparing them the only way to really explain just how the changes work for Perkins’ story vs. what King wrote back in 1980. Perkins took liberties with the idea of the short story and honestly it does make it a more fleshed out an appealing story.

But when I say they are different from one another, I mean it. They are so incredibly different that they feel like two separate takes on a similar idea. Which isn’t a bad thing. It’s a short story, you have more freedom to explore the themes there in a filmed adaptation.

So let’s explain what exactly makes King’s “The Monkey” different from Perkins’ The Monkey by breaking down the plot of both.

Hal Shelburn, his wife Terry, and their two sons Dennis and Petey go back to Casco, Maine to clear out the house of his Aunt Ida and Uncle Will. We learn through the story that Hal’s older brother Bill’s family is also there but it is Hal’s burden to bury when he discovers a toy monkey that he had as a child. Hal believes the monkey has an evil power: Wind it up and someone dies.

Through Hal’s memories, we learn that his friends died from the toy, maybe his father, he blames the monkey for the death of a beloved dog and so on and so forth. The return of the monkey into Hal’s life turns him into a jerk to his family. He’s rude to his wife and yelling at Dennis but it is Petey’s admittance that he doesn’t like the monkey that allows Hal to make moves to get rid of it for “good.”

Hal and Petey take the monkey back to Aunt Ida and Uncle Will’s home and Hal remembers a story from Uncle Will about the depth of Crystal Lake. Taking a boat out, Hal goes alone to throw the monkey (who has escaped a well in the past) overboard.

Despite the monkey trying to destroy Hal’s boat before he can make it to shore, Hal succeeds and makes it back to Petey before the monkey can claim him as a victim. The same cannot be said for the fish in the lake.

Perkins’ The Monkey is very different. We meet Pete Shelburn (Adam Scott) covered in blood in a pilot’s outfit trying to sell a monkey to a pawn shop. When the owner calls it a toy, he quickly responds that it is not one and to “never call it” a toy. The monkey itself is activated, playing a sinister song and when his drumming ends, so does the life of the owner of the pawn shop.

That’s our first introduction to The Monkey. So far, not that different but then things quickly shift. Pete did say that he took it home to his boys who didn’t like it, which is part of the King short story, but in Perkins’ version, Bill and Hal are twins. The younger twins are played by Christian Convery and the older versions of the brothers are played by Theo James.

Young Bill and Hal are not close. Their mother Lois (Tatiana Maslany) tries to be everything for them but it isn’t enough to change Bill. He is aggressive, rude to Hal, and not willing to change his reactions to his “younger” brother. Things take a turn when the two find the monkey in a closet filled with their father’s belongings.

Hal winds it up and nothing happens. But when the monkey is suddenly activated, it results in the death of their babysitter. In a moment of anger later in the movie, Hal uses the monkey with a clear intention: Kill Bill.

It doesn’t work and instead, Lois is a victim. Somehow, the monkey survives Hal’s brutal chopping up of it and a brotherly rivalry is born. More deaths, more twists, and Hal’s estranged son Petey (Colin O’Brien) leads us to the monkey’s full power and blood craving ways. We end the movie with no real finality to the monkey itself, never knowing what it will do next.

Now, looking at the two pieces of work, they are vastly different. “The Monkey” doesn’t really get to have the fleshed out relationship between the brothers and we don’t understand the monkey’s tricks and ways as well as we do in Perkins’ The Monkey. But King’s short story is eerie in that unknowing nature. Perkins’ takes a more comical approach to the absurd idea.

The death’s in “The Monkey” feel a little more tame. Easy explained away, justified, or ignored completely. Perkins’ made the “accidents” that claimed the monkey’s victims so outrageous that Hal and Bill could not ignore the reality before them.

But with all the differences between the two, I think it is a good thing that Perkins’ take on the story is so different. It has darker themes of fatherhood, family trauma, and revenge that the short story does not. The Monkey allows its characters to grow and Hal’s fear is a little more understandable since he does know exactly how this game works.

I almost wish other King adaptations would have the same bravery that Perkins’ does. Many are too faithful to the original text and we see the same stories repeated time and time again but this take on The Monkey is new and fresh and a fun comparison piece to the 1980 short story.

The Mary Sue is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy



👉 Click Here to read in detail 👈

Miatamil

Listed here the latest Trending News

I spotted Amorim's furious reaction - he knew what was coming from Man Utd

I spotted Amorim's furious reaction - he knew what was coming from Man Utd

Man Utd drew 2-2 against Everton in the Premier League on Saturday and here are the moments you might have missed.

Read more >> : Cick here

Share on : 👇
Twitter (X) Facebook truthsocial gettr pinterest whatsapp telegram
The man who unmasked cancer faker Belle Gibson written out of history

The man who unmasked cancer faker Belle Gibson written out of history

Nine has been accused of lying about its involvement in exposing notorious cancer faker Belle Gibson's web of deceit as it desperately tries to cash in on a new Netflix series about her life.

Read more >> : Cick here

Share on : 👇
Twitter (X) Facebook truthsocial gettr pinterest whatsapp telegram
BGT fans beg for KSI to return as judge after Bruno Tonioli stand-in

BGT fans beg for KSI to return as judge after Bruno Tonioli stand-in

KSI was a surprise addition to the judging panel of Britain's Got Talent, as he stepped in for Bruno Tonioli, and fans were desperate for the YouTube star to return

Read more >> : Cick here

Share on : 👇
Twitter (X) Facebook truthsocial gettr pinterest whatsapp telegram
What Unai Emery is doing to reignite Marcus Rashford's career

What Unai Emery is doing to reignite Marcus Rashford's career

Manchester United loanee Marcus Rashford helped inspire Aston Villa to a 2-1 victory over Chelsea in the Premier League on Saturday evening

Read more >> : Cick here

Share on : 👇
Twitter (X) Facebook truthsocial gettr pinterest whatsapp telegram
Luka Doncic, new-look Lakers dominate Nuggets to end 9-game win streak

Luka Doncic, new-look Lakers dominate Nuggets to end 9-game win streak

Weirdly, it was the Nuggets’ offense that wasn’t able to handle the new-look Lakers on Saturday.

Read more >> : Cick here

Share on : 👇
Twitter (X) Facebook truthsocial gettr pinterest whatsapp telegram
Dave Chappelle Declares Don’t Be “Discouraged” In “Very Difficult Time” To NAACP Image Awards; Jokes “All My Netflix Checks Cleared”

Dave Chappelle Declares Don’t Be “Discouraged” In “Very Difficult Time” To NAACP Image Awards; Jokes “All My Netflix Checks Cleared”

Dave Chappelle was given the NAACP Image Awards' President Award tonight & delivered some presidential remarks for a "very difficult time"

Read more >> : Cick here

Share on : 👇
Twitter (X) Facebook truthsocial gettr pinterest whatsapp telegram
Michaela Strachan suffers ITV Dancing on Ice blow despite being favourite to win competition

Michaela Strachan suffers ITV Dancing on Ice blow despite being favourite to win competition

The Winterwatch star has been a fan favourite since the beginning of the show

Read more >> : Cick here

Share on : 👇
Twitter (X) Facebook truthsocial gettr pinterest whatsapp telegram
Beauty in chaos: Japanese hail Hong Kong’s Kowloon Walled City film exhibition

Beauty in chaos: Japanese hail Hong Kong’s Kowloon Walled City film exhibition

Exhibition a hit for fans enthralled by aesthetics, martial arts moves and nostalgia of Twilight of the Warriors: Walled In.

Read more >> : Cick here

Share on : 👇
Twitter (X) Facebook truthsocial gettr pinterest whatsapp telegram
California governor asks Congress for nearly $40 billion for Los Angeles wildfire relief - World News

California governor asks Congress for nearly $40 billion for Los Angeles wildfire relief - World News

SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — California Gov. Gavin Newsom has asked Congress to approve nearly $40 billion in aid to help the Los Angeles area recover from January's devastating wildfires, which he said could become the costliest natural disaster in U.S. history.

Read more >> : Cick here

Share on : 👇
Twitter (X) Facebook truthsocial gettr pinterest whatsapp telegram
Britain’s Got Talent fans beg for KSI to replace Bruno after judging debut

Britain’s Got Talent fans beg for KSI to replace Bruno after judging debut

After just three days on the BGT judging panel, new recruit KSI had already won over legions of fans - with some viewers even calling for him to be a permanent addition to the show

Read more >> : Cick here

Share on : 👇
Twitter (X) Facebook truthsocial gettr pinterest whatsapp telegram
Helen Flanagan cruelly mum-shamed on night out with boyfriend's daughter

Helen Flanagan cruelly mum-shamed on night out with boyfriend's daughter

Former Coronation Street star and I'm a Celeb maven Helen Flanagan has come under fire for daring to enjoy a night out without her children as she hit the town with boyfriend Robbie Talbot and his daughter

Read more >> : Cick here

Share on : 👇
Twitter (X) Facebook truthsocial gettr pinterest whatsapp telegram
Yankees 3-Year Starter Has 4 Words to Describe Playing Future

Yankees 3-Year Starter Has 4 Words to Describe Playing Future

The New York Yankees have been active in free agency. One of their signings has left a three-year starter still searching for his next team.

Read more >> : Cick here

Share on : 👇
Twitter (X) Facebook truthsocial gettr pinterest whatsapp telegram
Rafael Devers Drama May Force Red Sox to Trade '40 Home Run' Slugger

Rafael Devers Drama May Force Red Sox to Trade '40 Home Run' Slugger

The controversy over which position $313.5 million slugger Rafael Devers will play in the Boston Red Sox infield may have repercussions for another player.

Read more >> : Cick here

Share on : 👇
Twitter (X) Facebook truthsocial gettr pinterest whatsapp telegram


These hashtags listed here are the most popular shared hashtags on Worldwide


Twitter (X), Inc. was an American social media company based in San Francisco, California, which operated and was named for its flagship social media network prior to its rebrand as X. In addition to Twitter, the company previously operated the Vine short video app and Periscope livestreaming service

Twitter (X) is one of the most popular social media platforms, with over 619 million monthly active users worldwide. One of the most exciting features of Twitter (X) is the ability to see what topics are trending in real-time. Twitter trends are a fascinating way to stay up to date on what people are talking about on the platform, and they can also be a valuable tool for businesses and individuals to stay relevant and informed. In this article, we will discuss Twitter (X) trends, how they work, and how you can use them to your advantage.

What are Twitter (X) Worldwide Trends?
Twitter (X) Worldwide trends are a list of topics that are currently being talked about on the platform and also world. The topics on this list change in real-time and are based on the volume of tweets using a particular hashtag or keyword. Twitter (X) Worldwide trends can be localized to a Worldwide country or region or can be global, depending on the topic's popularity.

How Do Twitter (X) Worldwide Trends Work?
Twitter (X) Worldwide trends are generated by an algorithm that analyzes the volume of tweets using a particular hashtag or keyword. When the algorithm detects a sudden increase in tweets using a specific hashtag or keyword, it considers that topic to be trending.

Once a topic is identified as trending, it is added to the list of Twitter (X) Worldwide trends. The topics on this list are ranked based on their popularity, with the most popular topics appearing at the top of the list.

Twitter (X) Worldwide trends can be filtered by location or category, allowing users to see what topics are trending in their area or in a particular industry. Additionally, users can click on a trending topic to see all of the tweets using that hashtag or keyword.