Tariff confusion reigns as Trump triggers biggest change to global trade in a century
The Trump administration's roll-out of sweeping global tariffs tariffs has prompted urgent questions about how the new taxes were calculated, how long they will last and what exactly the White House hopes to achieve with them.
The wide-ranging new tariffs announced by President Trump on Wednesday represent the biggest change to global trade in a century, prompting urgent questions about how the new taxes were calculated, how long they will last and what exactly the White House hopes to achieve with them.
Confusion over the details â and the fact that the rates Trump announced were much higher than most economists anticipated â has sent stocks tumbling and businesses and global leaders scrambling for clarity.
What are the tariffs?
Trump announced a baseline 10% tax on nearly all goods imported to the U.S. from every country in the world, undoing the decades-long era of mostly free global trade long supported by the United States.
Trump also vowed additional taxes on several dozen countries that sell more goods to the United States than they buy. He described the new measures as âreciprocal tariffs,â and said they were payback for other countries that unfairly tax U.S. goods.
âThey do it to us, and we do it to them,â Trump said. âVery simple.â
President Trump appears on a TV screen at the stock market in Frankfurt, Germany, on Wednesday.
(Michael Probst / Associated Press)
But many economists and investors quickly pointed out that the new rates appear to have nothing to do with foreign tariffs, and the White House later confirmed that was the case.
It released a document explaining that the administration used a calculation that took the U.S. trade deficit with individual trading partners, divided it by U.S. imports from that partner, and then divided the total in half.
âWhile these new tariff measures have been framed as âreciprocal tariffs,â what youâre really targeting are countries that have significant trade surpluses with the United States,â said Mike OâRourke, chief marketing strategist at Jones Trading.
The exact nature of the tariffs was kept a mystery until the last moment, with Trump meeting with economic advisors as late as Tuesday afternoon to finalize details.
Preparing tariff retaliation, U.S. allies say Trump will âbuckle under pressureâ
Why is Trump doing this?
Trump described Wednesday as âLiberation Day,â and said it will âforever be remembered as the day that American industry was reborn, the day Americaâs destiny was reclaimed, and the day that we began to make America wealthy again.â
He accused nations the world over â âfriend and foe alikeâ â of having âlooted, pillaged, raped and plunderedâ the United States. âOur country and its taxpayers have been ripped off for more than 50 years, but it is not going to happen anymore. Itâs not gonna happen,â Trump said.
But there have been conflicting messages from the White House about what exactly the tariffs seek to do.
At times, Trump and his advisors have described the tariffs as a negotiating tactic to force nations to drop trade barriers to American products â or to comply with other U.S. policy demands.
Administration officials have suggested in recent days that Trump might be willing to lower or end some of the just-announced tariffs depending on negotiations with individual countries. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said Thursday that Trump might cut tariffs on China by 20% if leaders there agree to do more to stop fentanyl trafficking.
At the same time, the Trump administration has promised that tariffs will help lure manufacturing back to the U.S. But to convince companies to move supply chains back to America, economists say tariffs would have to be sustained at high levels over a long period of time â not dropped.
Those seemingly incompatible goals are complicated by a third one: Trump has repeatedly said that he hopes the new tariffs will raise money for the U.S. Treasury.
Even in O.C. Trump country, some worry about how tariffs will hit their pocketbooks
Trump has pledged heâll use new revenue from tariffs to finance tax cuts, which analysts say would disproportionately benefit the wealthy.
What will the impact be?
In the near term, economists say tariffs will disrupt supply chains, shrink the global economy and increase costs for the average American family by thousands of dollars annually.
Prices for some products in U.S. stores, such as avocados, tomatoes and other produce from Mexico, may rise within a matter of days. Prices for other products â electronics, construction supplies and pharmaceuticals â may take a month or two to increase.
Some experts have questioned whether, in the long run, the U.S. can recoup the domestic manufacturing base that it gave up in favor of a globalized economy.
Trucks line up to cross the border into the U.S. from Mexico earlier this year.
(Gregory Bull / Associated Press)
âItâs not 1956. A small fraction of American workers work in manufacturing today, and manufacturing jobs are not, on average, better-paid than other working-class jobs,â James Surowiecki, the former financial columnist for the New Yorker, wrote on X. âAnd even if companies open more factories here, those factories will be highly automated, and create relatively few jobs.â
âOver the past three decades, we traded U.S. jobs and GDP growth for higher corporate profits and lower consumer prices,â said OâRourke, who added that it wonât be easy âto unwind three decades of globalization.â
While itâs possible that sustained tariffs could eventually bring more jobs to the U.S., he said, âyouâre also going to see corporate profits squeezed, youâre going to see higher consumer prices, higher inflation.â
What happens next?
Trump has shown a proclivity for enacting tariffs â and then suddenly reversing course. Thatâs what he did last month with tariffs against Canada and Mexico.
A fact sheet released by the White House this week said: âThese tariffs will remain in effect until such a time as President Trump determines that the threat posed by the trade deficit and underlying nonreciprocal treatment is satisfied, resolved, or mitigated.â
It said Trump may âincrease the tariff if trading partners retaliate or decrease the tariffs if trading partners take significant steps to remedy nonreciprocal trade arrangements and align with the United States on economic and national security matters.â
While it remains unclear how long the tariffs will last and whether they will achieve any of Trumpâs goals, the presidentâs announcement on Wednesday clarified his willingness to enact punishing tariffs. And he seems prepared, OâRourke said, to respond to any new tariffs from other countries with even bigger tariffs of his own.
âAnytime a nation threatens to retaliate, President Trump threatens a number three or four times the current number,â OâRourke said. âSo he has a zero tolerance policy retaliation.â